In the ever changing landscape of Aveeno products, it's not too surprising that the fairly niche Ultra Calming range has been caught in the crossfire. In particular, you may have noticed the unfortunate discontinuation of the relatively popular Ultra-Calming Daily Moisturizer from the line.
Today, we're here to lay out the alternative options, homing in especially on Aveeno's Positively Radiant products.
This post contains affiliate links; as an Amazon Associate we earn commission from qualifying purchases.
Aveeno Positively Radiant vs Ultra-Calming Daily Moisturizer
It's worth noting that you can still find the Ultra-Calming Daily Moisturizer at select retailers such as Amazon, but once existing stock runs out you're going to need a back up plan. Aveeno recommends that a like-for-like replacement would be the Calm+Restore Redness Relief Moisturizing Cream, but it doesn't have SPF 15.
Instead, we'd suggest taking a look at Aveeno's beloved Positively Radiant Daily Moisturizer as an alternative (since it contains SPF 15, and never seems to encounter the discontinuation wrath)!
First off, both moisturizers offer broad-spectrum SPF 15 sun protection, which is essential for defending your skin against future sun damage. Both products also have a rich cream texture, perfect for delivering that much-needed hydration to your skin. And, they're both hypoallergenic, oil-free, and non-comedogenic, making them suitable for most skin types without clogging your pores. You'll notice that both products contain fragrance, so there's no difference there.
Now, let's talk about the differences. The Positively Radiant moisturizer is formulated to even out skin tone and fight early signs of aging, like blotchiness and brown spots. It contains soy extract, which is known for its tone-correcting properties, and natural light diffusers for added radiance.
On the other hand, the Ultra Calming moisturizer focuses on soothing sensitive and irritated skin, reducing redness in as little as one week. Its star ingredient is Chrysanthemum Parthenium (Feverfew) Flower/Leaf/Stem Juice, which is clinically proven to rebalance and calm the skin.
The Positively Radiant moisturizer instead includes mica and titanium dioxide, which are natural light diffusers that help give your skin a radiant glow (which is the main point of the Positively Radiant range). The Ultra Calming moisturizer does not contain these.
If you're thinking about switching from the Ultra Calming moisturizer to Positively Radiant, expect some differences in terms of skin benefits. While the Positively Radiant moisturizer may not have the same soothing effect as the Ultra Calming one, it does offer tone-correcting benefits and adds radiance to your complexion.
There's nothing outrageously different in the formula that would be cause for concern for those with sensitive skin, but you might want to perform a patch test before fully committing to the Positively Radiant moisturizer. This will help you determine if the new product will suit your skin's needs without causing any unwanted reactions. We've been following this Reddit thread and the OP made the switch with no issues, though as always, YMMV (your mileage may vary).
In conclusion, Aveeno's Positively Radiant Daily Face Moisturizer SPF 15 could be a suitable alternative to the discontinued Ultra Calming moisturizer. Although they target different skin concerns, and the absence of Feverfew may be felt by the most redness-prone skin types, they share essential features such as SPF protection, texture, and suitability for most skin types. We hope this comparison helps you decide whether to make the switch, and we wish you happy, glowing skin!
Positively Radiant Daily Face Moisturizer SPF 15 by Aveeno
Our rating: ★★★★★
Helps even skin tone.
What makes it special? Want to add more radiance to your routine? Then this daily moisturizer is for you. With tone correcting soy and natural light diffusers, it works to fight the signs of early skin aging like blotchiness and brown spots. Meanwhile, the broad spectrum SPF 15 defends against future sun damage. Win, win.
Which skin types? For all skin types.
Ultra-Calming Daily Face Moisturizer SPF 15 by Aveeno (Discontinued)
Our rating: ★★★★★
Visibly reduces redness.
What makes it special? For sensitive skin, nothing’s more important than balance. That’s where this ULTRA-CALMING® Daily Moisturizer comes in. Be prepared to glow with Aveeno's exclusive CALMING FEVERFEW® formula, clinically proven to rebalance and soothe irritated skin. Gentle enough for daily use, you’ll see reduced redness in as little as one week.
Which skin types? For sensitive skin types.